Troxel Spirit vs. Tipperary Sportage; Helmet help!?

I need a new helmet and while browsing statelinetack.com I found the Tipperary Sportage, the reviews are immensely better and all around more positive. I like the look of the Tipperary and Spirit, so looks aren't a factor. I ride Hunt, am going to start jumping and also ride Western Pleasure, but I don't show at all. Have you had a better experience with one or the other?